| Year | St Andrew’s  | St. David’s  | St. George’s  | St. Patrick’s  |
| 1929 | J. Thompson | H. Vincent | G. Green | H. Powell |
| 1930 | L. Butler | M. Knight | R. Jansen | H. Powell |
| 1934 | H. Luschwitz S. Smith | H. McDonough V. Lobo | J. Marshall P. Pinto | H. Nicholas C. Cooke |
| 1936 | – Not available – | A. Butler | – Not available – | R. Simmons |
| 1938 | – Not available – | – Not available – | J. Ingham (More’s) Felix Fernandez (More’s) | F. Weston (Fisher’s) |
| 1939 | J. K. Aepen (Ogilvie’s) A. Morlini (Berchmans’) | Arthur Cooke (Southwell’s) | Lawrence D’Sylva (More’s) | E. Stephens (Fisher’s) Ambrose Ryder (Gonzaga’s) |
| 1940 | George Sellers Lawrence D’Sylva | Cecil Stephens Robert S. Sanford Noel Francis | D. MacBride | A. D’Souza Charles D’Costa |
| 1941 | A. Mirza | George Ferris | Denzil Ferris | Sohrab Poonawalla |
| 1942 | A. Mirza | Tony Fernandez | Clarence Ogle | Sohrab Poonawalla |
| 1943 | Vincent Estibeiro Joachim Fernandez | P. Wainwright | Edwin Thomas | Joseph Vanspall |
| 1944 | Joachim Fernandez | P. Wainwright | Edwin Thomas | D. Guha |
| 1945 | A. N. Reddy | P. Devaney | John Walters William Dias | M. Mathias |
| 1946 | W. Langford | O. Callanan | A. Nazareth | H. Roderick |
| 1947 | T. Woodward | A. David | A. Nazareth | Y. Somu |
| 1948 | Freddy Dias | Hilario Fernandes | Albert Ferris | Denzil D’Souza |
| 1949 | Alfred Lewis Freddy Dias | James Nazareth | Louis Michael | Cecil Fullinfaw |
| 1950 | Paschal Denis | Salus Nazareth | Richard Armstrong | John Thomas |
| 1951 | Lincoln Briggs | Eugene Cordeiro | Stafford Vernem | Patrick Cranenburgh |
| 1952 | Lincoln Briggs | Christopher Lynn | Basil Vernem | Frank Saldanha |
| 1953 | Sylvester D’Souza | Patrick Seymour | Arthur Godinho | Patrick Speechly |
| 1954 | Sylvester Saldanha | Lawrence Fownes | Edgar Bantleman | Cecil Noronha |
| 1955 | Moyeen Khaleeli | Robert Saldanha | Edgar Francis | Conrad De Rosario |
| 1956 | Jayasekhar B. Menon | F. Chandra Pereira | Ashly Gaynor | Norman Abraham |
| 1957 | John Saldanha | Philip Aviet | Eddie Lawyer | Jose Vallikappen |
| 1958 | Adolph Abraham | Michael Saldanha | Henry Taveira | S. Chakravarthy |
| 1959 | K.V. Nicholas | Denis Mathias | Nagaraj Sastry | Bashiruddin Babukhan |
| 1960 | Dinesh Bahadur | Ashley Knowles | K. S. Thomas | K. E. Eapen |
| 1961 | Sushil Kumar Mahajan V. J. Abraham | P. Jayaker | Irwin Tellis | Satish K. Raichur |
| 1962 | V. J. Abraham | P. Jayaker | Narendra Kumar | Alec Noronha |
| 1963 | Robin Chakravarti | George Cheriyan | Rui Saldanha | Vaughan Marten |
| 1964 | Brian Janes V. J. John | Ronald Coelho | Ronald J. Satur | Bernard Rodrigues |
| 1965 | V. J. John | Ronald Coelho | Bonaventure Andrade | Clarence Chandran |
| 1966 | Roy Chambers | Alan Machado | Robert Mascarenhas | Anthony Santiago |
| 1967 | Jude D’Souza | Reginald Fernandes | David Roby | Brian Kamath |
| 1968 | Thomas D’Souza Blasco Sobrinho | Dipankar Banerjee | Iftekhar Ahmed | Joseph Andrade |
| 1969 | K. N. Srikanth | Albert Shaw | Ittira Davis | M. C. Cariappa |
| 1970 | Ajit Bhide | E. Akthar | Ittira Davis | A. Muttukumaru |
| 1971 | Ajit Bhide | Alex Pillai | Francis Lobo | K. A. Thimaya |
| 1972 | Noel D’Sa | Philip Mascarenhas | Nicholas Pereira Luke Thomas | K. A. Thimaya |
| 1973 | David Castelino | Keith D’Couto | Bosco D’Souza | Srinivas Bhat |
| 1974 | Sunil Abraham | Michael Pereira | Mohan Abraham | Olavo D’Souza |
| 1975 | S. Manjunath | D. Pius | Michael Bakes | Trevor King |
| 1976 | Chaitanya Raina | Jamie Raghuram | Michael Jacquet | Rabindra Prabhu |
| 1977 | Prapanch Mandana | Eric D’Souza | Malcolm Panthaki | Prince F. Jacob |
| 1978 | Adrian Silgardo | S. Diwakar Rao | Joseph Xavier | P. S. Ramesh |
| 1979 | K. A. Appiah | Trevor Rodrigues | P. A. Medapa | Manoj B. Suvarna |
| 1980 | Nakul Shetty | David D’Souza | Mark de Magry | N. S. Prakash |
| 1981 | K. V. Pooviah | Vikrant Saravana | Roger Galway | Bobby Joseph |
| 1982 | Sarosh Saher | Simon Huang | Borys Mascarenhas | Jim Zachariah |
| 1983 | M. B. Chinappa | Hanif Somji | Joseph Huang | David Lobo |
| 1984 | Shirish Vijayendra | K. Girish Shankar | Everette Fernandes | Biju Anthony |
| 1985 | Prithvi Reddy | K. M. Appaiah | Tony Jacob Verghese | Rohan John |
| 1986 | Rajnish Bhandari | Ashwin Rao | Sandeep Reddy | Trevor Huang |
| 1987 | Aswath S. Honnavar | N. K. Dilip | Joe Joseph | Uday Zachariah |
| 1988 | Belloo Muthanna | Praveen D’Souza | Shuaib Razvi | Rahul Dravid |
| 1989 | Md. Farhan Sait | Anshul Chodha | Om Prakash Arora | Arun D’Souza |
| 1990 | Ashok Rao | Sumanth Kulkarni | Aditya Kaura | Vijay Dravid |
| 1991 | Ashwin Krishnan | Sachin Kukreja | Suraj Rajkumar | Narayan Sampath |
| 1992 | Vinay Mathias | Nandan Kamath | Rajiv Punja | Torun Mathias |
| 1993 | Ashok Inigo Roy | Akshay Madhavan | Sanjeev Shenoy | Sushil Shetty |
| 1994 | Ajit Sharma | Bijoy Pinto | Shaun Pinto | Mark Anthony Thomas |
| 1995 | Brojo Pillai | Rolf Marren | Rajeev Shenoy | Viren Punja |
| 1996 | Andrew De Nazareth | Aditya Appaya | C. Karthik | Sunil V. Kashyap |
| 1997 | Bipin G. Mathew | V. Vinod Kumar | Angelo Printer | Akhil Prabhu |
| 1998 | Nishan Joseph | Abhishek Kamath | Ashwin Mahabaleshwar | Sudhir Sukumar |
| 1999 | Jonathan Nicholas | Anup Krishnamurthy | Abhishek Chattopadhyay | Sandeep Mascarenhas |
| 2000 | Robin Mascarenhas | Chetan J. William | Arjun Rego | Alok Nayak |
| 2001 | Vikram Angelo | Godfrey Sylvester | Shailesh Aranha | Nitin Baliga |
| 2002 | Satchith Paulose | Neville De Nazareth | T. B. Ponnappa | Mario Jerome Arun |
| 2003 | Akhil Iyer | Gautam E. Pereira | Ajay Perumal | David Jacob |
| 2004 | Aquin Ritesh Pinto | Rohit Machado | Sujith Suresh | Kevin George |
| 2005 | Edward Rohit Murali | Saahas Patil | Leslie Joy Alex | David Thomas |
| 2006 | Noel Peter D’Souza | Rakesh Shialingam | Rinald Pereira | Suraj Bhaskar |
| 2007 | Rohan Joseph | Prinston Pereira | Aditya Balaram | Roger Joseph Lurshay |
| 2008 | Vinay A. | Karan Machado | Neil D’Souza | Nayan John Pinto |
| 2009 | Vaishnav Murthy | Kedar Nagarajan | D. Teja Sribharghav | Shamir Abraham |
| 2010 | Ranna D. Patil | Anirudh Jonnavithula | Ajinkya Harsha | Chirantan Suhrid |
| 2011 | Yash Bagrecha | Vijay R. Melwani | Suraj K. Tomy | Vaibhav Belliappa |
| 2012 | Nikhil Roy | Ajith S. | Shelwyn James S. | Ishwara M. Hegde |
| 2013 | Raul Aranha | Jason D’Silva | Hermon L. Menezes | Chirag Raju |
| 2014 | Kenneth George | Siddanth N. Swamy | Leander Lewis | Aayush Shah |
| 2015 | Derick Brian Saldanha | Sherwin Darryl D’Souza | Srivalsan Sunil | Vineet Braganza |
| 2016 | Suharsh Xavier | Jake Varun Rebello | K. S. Chirag Cariappa | Shaun Kurien Paul |
| 2017 | Tejas S. Rai | Kenneth Lemuel T. | Mallon L. D’Souza | B. S. Vishwanatha |
| 2018 | S. Varun Balaji | Jason Samuel | Carlin Joseph | Gaurav Sivappa |
| 2019 | Karl Jude Sandhu | Keane Paul Sandhu | Muhammad Rehan Shaikh | Shaun T. Shajan |
| 2020 | Darshan K. Thakurel | Jason Nikhil Joseph Felix | Rayhan Hassan | Bosco Jeo |
Old Boys AssociationSJBHS OBA